Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Elle Griffin's avatar

I totally feel religious without being religious! As though rituals add depth to life, even if they don’t add meaning.

This was a beautiful Shifra!

Expand full comment
stephen's avatar

thanks for this post, Shifra! Your part on science reminded me of the key distinction Wilhelm Dilthey made between science and the humanities: science seeks to *explain* the world, but it cannot *understand* it (in the elevated way that philosophy and religion can, for example). the tension inherent within a "scientific worldview" is that science cannot tell us what is meaningless or meaningful because its domain is exclusively the empirical world: what one can touch, taste, see, etc. So by definition, science cannot transcend the material world--that is for the other humanities disciplines 🕺🏻. in my opinion, because science will always be dependent on *language* to express the world, it will always be subordinate to disciplines that deal with language, and thus meaning (poetry, philosophy, history, etc.) 

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts